New Kent supervisors deny request to use public funding to upgrade subdivision’s private dam
An attempt by a private subdivision to garner funding from the county to upgrade a dam and spillway to state code has been denied in New Kent County.
New Kent Supervisors voted 4-1 to deny the request from the Woodhaven Property Owner’s Association (WPOA) for public funding to repair the dam, spillway, and road on Lakeshore Drive in the Woodhaven Shores subdivision during the Nov. 12 regular board meeting.
In the past few months, members of the WPOA have come to county leaders on several occasions to discuss the aforementioned matter. At the board of supervisors’ meeting, County Administrator Rodney Hathaway spoke about those discussions, saying that the WPOA had said it would cost $1.5 million to complete the repairs. However, Hathaway mentioned several factors that were not included, which would have pushed the total amount to $2.5 million to complete the project. The county administrator also said that several concerns have been posted on social media about the dam’s structure is untrue. He said that the dam does not need immediate repair according to New Kent engineers, but that the request comes because the dam is not built to current state standards to be deemed safe. Hathaway added that the dam was also constructed in the 1960s when the requirements were different.
During the public hearing, several residents of Woodhaven Shores and supporters took to the lectern, speaking on support for the project.
“I used to live in Woodhaven and the homeowner’s association to meet those requirements would come at a great expense,” commented Janet Holder. “That expense is very burdensome, and I know the county has priorities, but this problem goes far beyond resources of the small neighborhood.”
“This is state mandated,” chimed in Billy Helms. “I have been watching the changes for 42 years and the two dramatic changes is the volume of the water from the wetlands and sediment washing in the lake from construction filling up the lake at the bottom.
“New Kent is partially responsible for this for allowing new developments and construction,” he concluded.
Many of the residents who spoke about the potential of a catastrophic of the dam’s failure. According to those comments, Route 60 (Pocahontas Trail) would be subject to substantial flooding if the dam failed at any point. Citizens believe that Central Virginia Transportation Authority (CVTA) funding could be utilized, allowing it to be a bypass and exception for using public taxpayer funds for private infrastructure and roads.
Del. Jessica Anderson commented that she supports the project and would use her mechanisms to support it at the state level.
“That dam is designated as a high risk,” she said. “Any failure could block Route 60, which is designated as an evacuation route.
“Any approval at this level could be used to offer support and open doors for state funding,” Anderson concluded.
However, not everybody was in favor for seeing public taxpayer money being used to fund a private subdivision.
“I have compassion for the residents in Woodhaven Shores, but while compassionate, it’s a private dam,” said Gary Rouse. “Thirteen years ago is when the problem was first recognized.
“What would this project be if they [citizens of Woodhaven Shores] made it a priority in a timely manner back then?” he continued, pointing to $300,000 being raised to support the project. “There are 13 dams in New Kent with one rated as a high hazard and one rating as unsatisfactory.
“Are you willing to subject these taxpayers?” Rouse added as he ended his comments. “If the dam breaks, it is on the liability of Woodhaven Shores WPOA, not the federal, state, or New Kent government.”
“The more critical issue is why this subdivision was approved,” chimed in William Ward. “You can not spend local tax dollars for private projects. The public funds must be used for public use. That is what they [board of supervisors] is bound by.”
Holly Berry retorted the comments from opposition, saying that the residents of the subdivision were not being idle at the time.
“There are several misconceptions about the project, and we were not just standing by,” she said. “Woodhaven Shore residents inherited the dam and been working to bring it in compliance.
“We didn’t create the problem but didn’t walk away from it either,” Berry continued. “Our residents do not have unlimited resources. There is a different between public safety and public recreation (referencing allowing the public to use their plate) and granting unrestricted public access won’t solve problems.
“The dam failure would extend beyond our neighborhood,” she said as she wrapped up her comments. “The lake may be private, but the safety consequences are not.”
After more than an hour of comments during the public hearing, supervisors spoke about their feelings, with many saying they can relate to Woodhaven Shores residents but also raising concerns if it was approved.
“This was brought up to us because we can apply for funding procured through CVTA,” said District 5 representative Jordan Stewart. “However, some of my residents was for this and some were against it.”
“I feel for the residents and got an overwhelming response from District 3 who were not in favor of this,” commented District 3 supervisor Amy Pearson. “I don’t think it’s appropriate for the use of public funds for use of private projects.
“The best I could do is support a grant,” she added. “I am worried about other groups coming back and doing the same thing. Any decision like this would be setting a precedent.”
District 1 leader Thomas Evelyn told citizens that the problem is not at the county level, but at the state level.
“The state should step up to the play if they are concerned,” he said. “The state is the one giving the mandate and not providing you all the funds.
“My concern is the liability to the county,” Evelyn continued. “We have 13 dams in the county, and like Mr. Stiers said about not being in the housing business at last month’s meeting, we aren’t in the dam business.”
Evelyn continued, reading the original deed that saw the transfer of the property that including the dam, lake, the bottom of the lake, and all other property to the association.
“Would the county be liable?” he said, mentioning if the county took over. “I would reach out to the state if they are the ones mandating it.”
District 2 representative John Moyer agreed with Evelyn, saying that the problem has been ongoing for several years and asked if the WPOA was doing their part.
“Is everyone paying their dues?” he asked. “I ask this because the last time from my understanding is that when VDOT (Virginia Department of Transportation) offered to take over the roads, you all said no because they were private roads.”
District 4 and board chairman Ron Stiers spoke in favor of the homeowners, referencing the impact of any catastrophic failure to the dam.
“CVTA funds are not county funds,” he said. “They are gasoline taxes and we receive 30 to 40 percent from non-residents.
“There are 1,000 to 1,500 vehicles in Woodhaven Shores that pay into the CVTA,” Stiers continued. “If that dam breaks, it would wipe out Route 60 and CSX Railroad.”
Stiers asked if a motion needed to be made. After a few moments, Evelyn made a motion to deny providing public funds for the project but also directing county staff to work with the state to address the project. The denial of the project passed 4-1, with Stiers casting the lone dissenting vote.
In other matters conducted by the board of supervisors:
–Approved $747,173 to Mosely Architects for the architectural and engineering of the new county courthouse. Hathaway said that there is a proposed location for the new building between The Ordinary and Cumberland Road. The county administrator says preliminary studies for RPA, study, and road entry are underway.
–Updated the progress on the new elementary school project. Hathaway says that a site has been identified but negotiations are still ongoing. Hathaway believes that it will not be until Spring 2027 when an agreement for the location will be locked down and that he will continue to work with the superintendent of schools and the school board on the matters.

